In the world of fantasy baseball, points leagues offer a unique challenge and opportunity for managers. These leagues reward players for their volume and discipline, rather than flashy stats and ratios. While some may prefer the traditional approach, I'm here to highlight some overlooked gems who could be the key to your league's success. Let's dive into some under-rostered players who could be the difference between a good team and a great one.
Dillon Dingler, Catcher (DET)
What makes Dingler particularly fascinating is his ability to provide a solid floor in points leagues. While he may not have the pop of some top catchers, his contact skills and plate discipline are invaluable. Over the past 80 games, Dingler has emerged as one of the top catchers in the league, batting in the middle-third of a potent Tigers lineup. His 14 runs driven in to begin the season speak to his consistency and ability to contribute in points leagues. Personally, I think he's a must-have in 12-team, one-catcher leagues, and his availability in over half of ESPN leagues makes him a steal.
Josh Naylor, First Baseman (SEA)
What many people don't realize is that Naylor is a proven talent who has provided value over the past several seasons. While his slump to begin the season has caused some concern, his career .265 batting average suggests that better days are ahead. After a career year in speed last season, Naylor has yet to steal a base in 2026, but his ability to get aboard and contribute in other ways makes him a valuable asset. If fantasy managers are starting to bail on Naylor, I'm willing to cash in on their impatience and scoop the veteran infielder. In my opinion, he's a great buy-low candidate.
Carlos Correa, Shortstop/Third Baseman (HOU)
One thing that immediately stands out is Correa's ability to lead off against lefties and bat in the middle of the lineup against righties. His improved walk rate and reduced strikeout rate early in the season suggest that his decision-making at the plate is looking better. Paired with an 8.5% barrel rate, Correa appears more comfortable back home in Houston after his tenure in Minnesota. While he's slugging just .375, his eligibility at both shortstop and third base makes him a versatile asset for fantasy managers. If you take a step back and think about it, Correa's availability in just 51.1% of ESPN leagues makes him a great add for any points league.
Trent Grisham, Outfielder (NYY)
What makes Grisham particularly interesting is his exceptional understanding of the strike zone. His reduced strikeout rate and increased walk rate, along with a 93.0% zone-contact rate, make him a valuable asset in points leagues. While he's been largely unlucky with a .163 BABIP, his expected batting average (.211) suggests that positive regression is on the horizon. If you're looking for a buy-low candidate, Grisham is available in over two-thirds of all fantasy leagues and could be a great addition to your team.
Michael Wacha, Pitcher (KCR)
What makes Wacha particularly fascinating is his ability to generate a high CSW percentage with his fastball, while also missing bats with his off-speed offerings. With upcoming matchups against the strikeout-heavy Orioles and Athletics, Wacha is a viable starting pitching option. In my opinion, he's a great add for any points league, and his availability in over 25% of leagues makes him a steal. If you're looking for a reliable starting pitcher, Wacha is a great choice.
Kenley Jansen, Relief Pitcher (DET)
What makes Jansen particularly interesting is his ability to secure saves and fantasy points for his managers. With four consecutive clean innings and saves in each of his last four outings, Jansen is a reliable option for any points league. While he's available in over 40% of ESPN leagues, I think he's a must-have in nearly every 12-team league. If you're looking for a reliable closer, Jansen is a great choice.
In conclusion, these under-rostered players offer a unique opportunity for fantasy managers to gain an edge in their points leagues. While some may be hesitant to add them to their roster, I believe that their value and potential make them worth the risk. If you're looking to make your league mates think you got your hands on Biff's Almanac, these players are the key to your success.
